How to Distinguish Noise from Drift?
Table of content
Introduction
Clare, an experienced chromatographer, was preparing a series of critical samples when she noticed an issue. Initially, her instrument performed flawlessly, delivering stable baselines and clear chromatographic peaks. However, as the runtime extended, the baseline became erratic. What began as minor disturbances soon escalated into noticeable noise, and at times, the baseline drifted steadily in one direction.
Frustrated, Clare wondered: What causes these issues, and how can they be resolved?
If you’ve ever faced similar challenges, this article will help you distinguish between noise and drift, understand their causes, and implement practical solutions.
Understanding Noise and Drift
Noise and drift are key indicators of detector stability in chromatography systems.
Noise
Noise refers to random fluctuations in the detector’s output signal when no analyte is passing through. It is denoted as Nd and classified into two types: short-term noise and long-term noise.
-
Short-term noise
- Commonly called “spikes,” short-term noise appears as fine, hair-like disturbances on the baseline.
- It results from high-frequency signal variations, such as pump pulsations or electronic interference.
- While it does not compromise peak resolution, it can affect detection limits.
- Solutions: Use appropriate filters to minimize these high-frequency disturbances.
-
Long-term noise
- Exhibited as slow, wave-like or irregular baseline undulations.
- Caused by low-frequency disturbances with similar frequencies to chromatographic peaks.
- Sources include detector instability, temperature fluctuations, flow rate inconsistencies, contamination, or bubbles in the mobile phase.
- For refractive index detectors, temperature and pressure changes significantly impact long-term noise due to alterations in refractive index within the detection cell.
- Solutions: Improve detector design, control the mobile phase temperature, and eliminate flow inconsistencies.
Drift
Drift is a gradual, unidirectional shift in the baseline over time. Unlike noise, drift does not blur chromatographic peaks but necessitates frequent baseline adjustments.
Common causes of drift include:
- Unstable power supply,
- Gradual temperature changes,
- Flow rate inconsistencies,
- Column contamination or phase degradation,
- Lack of mobile phase equilibrium after a solvent change.
To minimize drift, stabilize environmental factors such as temperature and ensure proper column and solvent equilibrium before analysis.
Addressing Noise in UV Detectors
Noise in UV detectors originates from two main sources: the detector itself and the separation system.
Detector Noise
UV detectors measure light intensity changes based on sample absorption. Without analyte absorption, the signal depends on the light source intensity, optical system efficiency, and photoelectric conversion efficiency. Key contributors to detector noise include:
Light source degradation:
Deuterium lamps are commonly used in UV detectors. Over time, their light intensity diminishes, causing increased noise. Regular replacement of the deuterium lamp is essential to maintain signal stability.Optical contamination:
Dust accumulation on optical components reduces light transmission and increases scattering. Prolonged UV exposure can degrade optical materials, further elevating noise. Routine cleaning and preventive maintenance are necessary to ensure optimal performance.
Separation System Noise
Separation system noise often correlates with mobile phase flow rate changes. Factors affecting separation system noise include:
Temperature fluctuations:
Variations in temperature alter the refractive index of the mobile phase, causing baseline noise. Solutions include temperature control using heat exchangers to maintain thermal equilibrium.Pressure fluctuations:
Pump pulsations induce pressure changes, which can affect the refractive index and increase baseline noise. Adding pulse dampeners can mitigate this issue.
By systematically altering the mobile phase flow rate, the noise source can be identified. For example, if noise varies with flow rate changes, it likely originates from the separation system.